Peer Review Process
Peer Review Policy
The Revista Multidisciplinar do Nordeste Mineiro – REMUNOM adopts a double-blind peer review system as the standard procedure for evaluating manuscripts submitted to the journal. Under this model, the identities of the authors are not disclosed to the reviewers, and the identities of the reviewers remain anonymous to the authors throughout the evaluation process.
Initial Editorial Screening
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening (desk review) conducted by the editorial team. At this stage, the following aspects are assessed:
- suitability for the journal’s aims and scope;
- originality and relevance of the work;
- compliance with the journal’s editorial guidelines;
- scientific and methodological quality;
- ethical aspects;
- evidence of plagiarism, self-plagiarism, or other forms of research misconduct;
- adequacy of references and manuscript structure.
Manuscripts that do not meet the minimum editorial or scientific requirements may be rejected at this stage before being forwarded for peer review.
Double-Blind Peer Review
Manuscripts considered suitable after the initial editorial screening are forwarded to at least two independent reviewers with knowledge and experience relevant to the subject area of the manuscript.
REMUNOM uses a double-blind peer review system, ensuring that:
- reviewers do not have access to the authors’ identities during the evaluation process;
- authors do not have access to the reviewers’ identities;
- review reports are treated confidentially;
- reviewers are selected based on their academic and scientific expertise related to the manuscript’s subject matter.
Reviewers assess, among other aspects, the originality, scientific relevance, theoretical foundation, methodological adequacy, presentation and interpretation of results, quality of discussion, conclusions, and contribution of the study to its field of knowledge.
Reviewer Recommendations and Divergent Opinions
After the evaluation, reviewers may recommend:
a) acceptance of the manuscript;
b) acceptance subject to revisions;
c) major revision followed by a new evaluation; or
d) rejection of the manuscript.
When there is a significant disagreement between the opinions of the two reviewers, the manuscript may be forwarded to a third independent reviewer, whose report will assist the editorial team in reaching a decision.
Manuscript Revisions
When revisions are requested, authors must submit a revised version of the manuscript and respond to the comments and recommendations made by the reviewers.
Depending on the nature and extent of the requested changes, the manuscript may be returned to the same reviewers or sent to other specialists for further evaluation.
Completion of the requested revisions does not guarantee acceptance of the manuscript.
Editorial Decision
The final editorial decision is the responsibility of the Editor handling the manuscript, taking into consideration the reviewers’ reports, the scientific quality of the work, compliance with the journal’s editorial policies, and the authors’ responses during the revision process.
Reviewer reports constitute technical and scientific recommendations and support the editorial decision, but they do not replace the journal’s editorial responsibility.
Editorial decisions are made independently of commercial or financial interests. Publication fees, when applicable, do not influence the peer review process or the decision to accept or reject a manuscript.
Independence and Conflicts of Interest
Editors and reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest involving the authors, institutions, funders, or the content of the manuscript.
When a conflict of interest that may compromise the independence of the evaluation is identified, the editor or reviewer involved must withdraw from the process, and another independent professional will be appointed.
REMUNOM seeks to ensure that reviewers do not have relationships or interests that could compromise the impartiality and independence of the scientific evaluation.
Special Issues and Supplements
Articles submitted to special issues, thematic issues, supplements, or special calls for papers are subject to the same editorial, scientific, ethical, and peer review standards applied to articles published in regular issues of REMUNOM.
All manuscripts eligible for scientific evaluation and published in these issues must undergo double-blind peer review conducted by at least two independent reviewers.
The participation of guest editors or coordinators of special issues does not reduce or replace the journal’s peer review requirements.
When a guest editor, member of the editorial team, or member of the editorial board has a conflict of interest involving a particular manuscript, that person must not participate in the evaluation or editorial decision concerning that manuscript.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts submitted to REMUNOM are treated as confidential documents throughout the editorial process.
Editors, reviewers, and other participants in the editorial process must not disclose, use, or share information, data, results, or ideas contained in submitted manuscripts prior to publication, unless expressly authorized by the authors.
Commitment to Editorial Integrity
REMUNOM keeps its peer review process separate from the journal’s financial and administrative decisions. Publication fees, institutional affiliations, authors’ nationality, or any other factor unrelated to scientific merit do not determine the editorial decision.
The purpose of the peer review process is to ensure the scientific quality, integrity, transparency, and reliability of the works published by the Revista Multidisciplinar do Nordeste Mineiro.
